Your kid can't find their shoe, there's a meltdown over a math worksheet, a friend drama at recess — and the easiest move is just to fix it. “Here's your shoe.” “The answer's 12.” “Just don't play with her then.” Done, right?
Except every time we do that, we're kind of telling our kid, without meaning to, “I don't think you've got this.” And what we want is the opposite message: “I trust you to figure this out — I'm right here if you need me.”
There's this idea in psychology called self-efficacy — basically, do you believe your own actions can actually change what happens to you? And kids don't get that from us telling them they're capable. They get it from actually solving stuff. Even small stuff. That little “oh, I did that” moment? That's the whole engine.
So here's the mindset shift: go from being the fixer to being the coach.
Quick example. Kid comes home bummed because a friend didn't want to play at recess. You could say, “That's so mean, don't be friends with her anymore.” Solved! Sort of. But you did all the thinking.
Or — you could say, “Ugh, that sounds like it stung. What do you think was going on with her today?” That one question turns it into their problem to think through, not yours to hand a verdict on.
Okay, so how do you actually do this in real time, when you're tired and just want the whining to stop? Four steps, super quick:
Step One — Identify the Problem
Just get them to say what's wrong. Sounds obvious, but half the time a kid's upset and can't even articulate why yet. If their brain is in “offline” mode, meaning fight-or-flight mode, you need to pause and come back to the issue when they’re calm and hopefully then they can articulate what the problem is.
Step Two — What’s Causing the Problem: Ask, Don't Tell
“What could you try?” And then — this is the hard part — let it be quiet for a second. Don't fill the silence with your answer. Give them the second to think. If they don’t have any ideas, just go to Step 3.
Step Three — Brainstorm: Think It Through Together
I really think brainstorming works best by starting with a question like: “Should we brainstorm some ideas together?” This tests to see if they’re ready or not. If they say no, go back to waiting for them to be calm. However, if they come up with any ideas, even slightly weird ones, don't correct them right away. Ask, “What do you think would happen if you tried that?” Let them predict the outcome themselves. If you offer suggestions make them generic, not personal. Don’t use “You should try XYZ…” it puts too much pressure to perform and can close down the learning. Instead use something like: “Some kids might try XYZ.. Would that work for you?”
Step Four — Solutions Experiment: Let Them Try, Then Circle Back
This is the one we skip most. We help brainstorm and then swoop in to execute because we're nervous it'll flop. Don't. Let them try, and afterward just ask, “How'd that go? Anything you'd do differently?” That's where solutions and problem-solving skills sink in.
Classic example — siblings fighting over a toy. Instead of playing judge, try: “What's the problem? What's a fix that feels fair to both of you?” Maybe they land on a timer for turns. Maybe something else. Doesn't matter if it's not what you would've picked — it's theirs now, and they'll learn over time that they’re capable and can reach for those skills again if you allow them to grow.
And here's the payoff — this compounds. The five-year-old who practices this stuff turns into the ten-year-old who can handle a friend conflict without you refereeing, who turns into the teenager who can navigate a hard conversation on their own. None of that comes from us handing over the right answer every time. It comes from us giving them thousands of tiny chances to find it themselves, with us just nearby. Steady. Not rescuing.
Bonus: it's honestly less exhausting for you too. You don't have to be everyone's fixer 24/7. You just have to believe they can do it.
So, one thing to try this week — next time your kid brings you a problem, before you jump to the fix, just ask: “What do you think you could do?” See what they come up with. Might surprise you.
By the way, I found a terrific poster for you to help your family learn the steps! It’s for teachers but… that’s who parents are, we’re teachers! Grab this on Amazon: PROBLEM SOLVING POSTER